Episode 441

Why Doing Your Best Turns Into Pressure for Highly Sensitive People and How to Find Ease Again

Show Notes

What if the stress you feel isn’t because you care too much—but because caring has quietly turned into pressure?

If you’re a highly sensitive person, you’ve probably experienced ordinary tasks becoming surprisingly stressful. Whether it’s writing an email, preparing a presentation, or planning something meaningful, this episode explores why genuine care can slowly transform into perfectionistic pressure—and how recognizing that shift can help you feel calmer, more creative, and more confident.

In this episode, you’ll discover:

  • Why highly sensitive people often feel pressure around the things they care about most.
  • The subtle mental shift that turns doing your best into trying not to get it wrong.
  • How to recognize self-pressure earlier so you can care deeply without carrying the weight of perfectionism.

 

Listen now to learn how to break free from self-imposed pressure while keeping the care, thoughtfulness, and high standards that make you who you are.

Listen

You can listen to this podcast wherever you like to enjoy your podcasts. Just open your favorite podcast app now and search for the podcast named, “Stress Management for Highly Sensitive People.” 

If you’re new to podcasts, here’s a review article by PCMagazine on the best podcast apps to use. 

Or you can listen to this episode in your browser here:

Watch

If you prefer video, you will find almost all of the same content from the podcast in video format below.

Podcast Transcript

 By the end of this episode, you’ll understand why highly sensitive people often don’t realize when doing their best has turned into self-pressure, and what becomes possible when you begin noticing that shift sooner. In this episode, you’ll discover why highly sensitive people often feel pressure around things they genuinely care about, what happens internally when doing something well quietly becomes trying not to get it wrong, and how things can begin to feel different when you recognize the shift from caring to pressure.

This is an edition of Strategy Fridays, where we think about specific things you can do to help manage stress as a highly sensitive person. Let’s think of some situations where you wanna do a good job with something. Maybe you’re almost finished writing an email and you wanna write a nice response in reply to someone.

Or maybe you’re recording a presentation and you wanna do a good job with it. Or maybe you’re cleaning the kitchen before guests arrive and you want to do a good job with that. Or same thing, maybe you’re trying to choose a birthday card that will be just right for the person that you’re going to give it to.

Or maybe you’re planning a vacation and you wanna do a really nice job so that everyone has a really good experience. Now, none of these situations are objectively stressful. They’re actually things that can be enjoyable to do. Yet somehow they become stressful. They move from something you enjoy doing into something that comes with a lot of pressure and stress, and can be something that, uh, you may even wanna avoid or get through somehow.

Have you ever noticed that you can in- genuinely enjoy doing something well until a certain point where somewhere along the way it starts to feel like pressure?

Many HSPs, when they experience this, conclude that they care too much, right? That’s the line that we’ve been given over and over by so– by the world. You know, you got… You care too much. You think too much. You care too much. You’re too sensitive. You’re too much, right? That’s what we’ve been hearing since we were young, and the world keeps repeating it to us.

But what if that’s not actually what’s going on? I mean, we know that from a certain point of view, this is a prejudice, right? This is the world’s prejudice against people who are sensitive. But I think it’s more than that. It’s not necessarily caring that is the issue at all, and people are pointing towards caring, but what’s really going on?

Caring doesn’t usually hurt. It doesn’t hurt to care. It doesn’t. It doesn’t hurt to wanna do a good job. In fact, it brings a certain invigoration and excitement and joy. But somewhere along the way, that joy gets pinched. That excitement gets dampened. And so what’s going on there? How does that happen? How does doing something we really like and wanna do a nice job with it turn into something that ends up being stressful

So it begins very simply. The simple first version is, “I’d like to do a good job with this.” This is a perfectly healthy thought. There’s no stress in it. There’s… You can see the goal. You can kind of see the, the end vision of where this is going. You’re starting to get excited. Now, how do I get there? And you’re looking at the details.

How can I do a really nice job with this? So healthy, so real, so, so invigorating, and this is what we naturally do as highly sensitive people. In fact, we do this in a way better than anyone else because we’re capable of seeing what the job is really asking for, and we’re capable of seeing what all the steps are that may be needed to get from here to there.

Like, this is the, the, the strength of being a highly sensitive person. We see where we are, we see what needs to be done, and we see where we want to get to. So wanting to do a good job, there’s no stress there. So then what happens is it shifts slightly. “I really want this to go well.” Okay, it’s still healthy, right?

This is the thought inside. “I really want this to go well. I’m still excited. I wanna, you know, I wanna get an A,” right? “I wanna, I wanna really do a good job. I want this to be a success. I want everyone to have a great time. I wanna be– I want it to be something that I feel satisfied with. I want this to really go well.”

Okay? So it’s, it’s getting like there’s a slight difference between that and, “I’d like to do a good job.” There’s like a little more, you could say pressure, but it’s very, very, very mild. It’s just a slight sharpening and almost like the energy is compressing in the direction that you wanna go in And then it can go one step further, and this is where it starts to shift in a noticeable way.

The thought, instead of being, “I want this to go really well,” starts shifting into, “I hope I don’t mess this up.” Now we’ve crossed over a line. Now there’s, there’s a different feeling entering the room. Instead of being excited, now I’m a little bit fearful. Now I’m like, “I hope I don’t mess this up. Gosh, I hope this really…

I hope that this goes really well.” Right? Like this, this feeling of, if I mess this up, there could be repercussions, or people are not gonna be happy, or I’m gonna be unhappy with it. Like, this is beginnings of a stressful experience. So notice what happened. Like, the mind starts with a very excited, healthy kind of direction, “I like to do a good job,” maybe even sharpens that a little bit, “I want this to go really well,” and then starts going across into, “I hope I don’t mess this up.”

And that’s when stress begins. Then it can just go further from there. “I can’t get this wrong.” That’s when it becomes super stressful. It’s like not just a hope that I don’t mess this up, it’s I can’t get this wrong. I better not make even one mistake. Imagine playing a musical instrument and thinking, “I can’t make even one mistake.”

The amount of pressure you would have, and the longer you play, the more pressure it is, because how long can you go without making one mistake? Like, this is where stress and pressure start taking over what was actually started out to be a very enjoyable, exciting, invigorating kind of experience. So nothing outside has changed in all of this.

Only the relationship to the task has changed. Only what you’re thinking has changed

So why would your system do that? It seems strange that it would go from such an excited positive energy into a kind of negative energy of trying to avoid making even one mistake. I don’t think that the system is trying to make you miserable. I don’t think it’s trying to, to shut you down, even though it has that effect.

I think it’s trying to actually protect something. And when you look a little bit deeper, there’s often some other past experience coming in, some experience with criticism in the past or some experience with rejection in the past. Maybe you did something, you did a really good job, and someone found the one flaw, and that was all they focused on, and it just felt like, “Oh.”

So you, you remember that instinctively, and then you don’t want to repeat that experience. So this is what I mean by your system trying to protect you from something. Or maybe you were embarrassed, like there was something you did in some small… Some– maybe it was public or something and, and that flaw became something that got focused on and, and you started feeling bad about it.

Or maybe you disappointed someone. You’d had great hopes for doing something really exciting and, and something they would really like, and then turns out they didn’t like it or they were critical about it. Maybe you felt inadequate in some way. So these past experiences, these past memories get projected into the future as fears that that could happen again.

“Oh my God, I don’t want that feeling of, of embarrassment again. I don’t want to be put down or rejected again.” And so now the goal has quietly shifted, uh, almost without noticing. It just quietly shifts. Originally, what was the goal? The goal was to try to do something meaningful, to try to do something well, and that’s what was exciting and you wanted to create something.

You wanted to see if you could do it and like it’s… it feels like a kid, just like, “Oh yeah, I wanna see how far I can go with this.” And then what happens is when that, that fear starts coming in, the goal shifts over to trying to avoid something painful So th- without even noticing, the goal of what you’re doing has changed, and so the whole thing changes.

Doing something well quietly becomes trying not to get it wrong. It’s a very different thing. One thing is trying to do something well. The other is trying not to get it wrong So when that happens, the natural result is pressure, because how can you possibly avoid not doing anything wrong? Even when we speak, there’s a million little ways that we make little mistakes, and then we just naturally correct on the fly and everything.

But, but, like, it’s natural to make mistakes, even if you’re a fluent speaker, if you’re a native speaker. Everything. Like, there’s a constant, uh, a constant adjustment that we are always doing as we’re, as we’re creating or interacting in any way. And so this artificial idea of having to do it perfectly and not get– make any mistake to avoid those feelings of those painful feelings that we had in the past creates an enormous pressure.

‘Cause what are the chances we’ll actually be able to do that? It’s slim to nil. So when that pressure comes in, then what happens is it starts to narrow our attention. It, it actually is, it’s not very helpful for the creative process. It starts to create internal tension. It starts to steal away our creativity, and it makes ordinary decisions feel like they’re huge and so important and I can’t make one mistake.

It makes finishing a project seem difficult, ’cause how am I ever get to that finish point where everything is completely flawless and there’s no chance of being criticized? So it can turn enjoyable things into obligations So the irony is that pressure is trying to help you do better, right? That’s the theory.

Oh, I do well under pressure. Uh, that’s not true for HSPs, but for a lot of people, they talk like that. You know, pressure, it’s like the idea, like the fake idea is that it’s trying to help you do better. But what actually happens when you bring pressure into a situation is then the outcomes n- actually become worse.

Your experience becomes worse, and your ability to perform becomes worse. And if you’re a highly sensitive person, that is one of the worst situations for us to perform under pressure, whether it’s self-induced pressure or pressure from outside. When we feel pressure, then we can not think. If you’ve ever noticed, your mind just freezes.

That is the experience of highly sensitive people

So pressure often disguises itself as caring. That’s the weird thing. Pressure sneaks in while we’re excited about doing something and then, and then takes over without even asking if it could join the party and then, um, suddenly is running the show

The f- the thing is though, if you don’t have pressure, you can still care deeply. You can still be conscientious. You can still have high standards. You can still take pride in your work Pressure isn’t what creates excellence. Pressure is what gets attached to excellence. It’s like a, I don’t know, like a tapeworm or something.

You know? It’s like a parasite, a leech or something. It just comes along for the ride, and then it suddenly it’s running the show. But what’s the real deal is a natural excitement that we feel inside to create something, to do something well, to care the way we naturally care. Pressure is an artifact, an extra And what I’ve found is that freedom doesn’t usually begin by lowering your standards.

You know, people always say, “Stop caring so much.” Well, that’s not the answer. As an HSP, you’re gonna care so much naturally because that’s who you are. That’s what… You’re made that way to care. So freedom doesn’t come from lowering your standards. It begins by recognizing this shift from excitement to pressure earlier on.

Because if you don’t notice when caring becomes pressure, you’ll naturally believe pressure is simply a part of caring, and that’s a very different experience So if you’re starting to recognize how often doing your best quietly turns into pressure and you’re tired of ordinary tasks feeling much more stressful than they actually need to be, and what you really want is to care deeply about the things that matter to you without feeling like everything has to be perfect, then I created something to help with exactly that.

It’s called the Perfectionism Self-Check. It’s a short printable guide designed to help highly sensitive people recognize when healthy care has quietly turned into self-pressure. Not so you can lower your standards, but so you can catch that shift earlier and return to a calmer, more grounded way of approaching things that matter to you.

You can download it for free. Just go to the show notes and click on the first link you find, or go to trueinnerfreedom.com/perfectionism-self-check.

Are You Ready to Reduce Overwhelm
and Stress in Your Life?

Take the HSP Stress Test now. Not only will you learn if you are a highly sensitive person (HSP) but you will gain valuable insights into your levels of anxiety, depression, and overall stress. You’ll also get a free 15-minute Inner Freedom Call to uncover what’s holding you back and help you step into a life of true inner freedom and fulfillment.

Stress Management for Highly Sensitive People

Are you a highly sensitive person (HSP) or someone who identifies as hypersensitive or neurodivergent? This podcast is dedicated to helping highly sensitive people (HSPs) navigate overwhelm and stress by using The Work of Byron Katie—a powerful method for questioning stressful thoughts and finding true inner freedom.

We dive deep into stress management strategies, coping with stress, and stress relief methods specifically tailored for HSPs. Learn how to manage emotions, especially negative ones, and explore effective stress reduction techniques that go beyond the surface to address the root causes of anxiety and pressure.

Whether you’re interested in learning how to lower stress, handle stress and pressure, or reduce stress through practical techniques, we provide insights and support based on The Work of Byron Katie. Discover how this transformative approach can help you decrease stress, find inner peace, and create balance in your life.

Join us to learn about various coping strategies for stress, all designed to support HSPs in their journey toward emotional well-being.