Episode 444

Why Raised Voices Feel So Powerful for Highly Sensitive People & How to Stay Connected to Yourself

Show Notes

Have you ever felt like someone raising their voice suddenly leaves you with no choice but to argue, give in, or somehow make them feel better?

For highly sensitive people, someone else’s anger or emotional intensity can quickly become overwhelming. Your attention can shift away from what you think, want, and experience—and toward figuring out how to calm the other person down. But their emotional state doesn’t have to determine yours.

  • Recognize when your attention shifts away from yourself so you can respond without automatically fighting, freezing, or complying.
  • Stay grounded in your own perspective while still genuinely listening to what the other person is experiencing.
  • Reduce the overwhelm of emotional pressure by remembering that someone else’s intensity doesn’t make their perspective more valid—or yours less important.

 

Play this episode to learn how staying connected to yourself can help you face raised voices and emotional pressure with more choice, less overwhelm, and a stronger sense of inner freedom.

Listen

You can listen to this podcast wherever you like to enjoy your podcasts. Just open your favorite podcast app now and search for the podcast named, “Stress Management for Highly Sensitive People.” 

If you’re new to podcasts, here’s a review article by PCMagazine on the best podcast apps to use. 

Or you can listen to this episode in your browser here:

Watch

If you prefer video, you will find almost all of the same content from the podcast in video format below.

Podcast Transcript

 By the end of this episode, you’ll understand why someone raising their voice can feel so overwhelming for highly sensitive people, and what begins to change when you stop treating their emotional state as something you have to fix. In this episode, you’ll discover why a raised voice can make it feel like you have no choice, even when you do, how your attention quietly shifts away from yourself and onto the other person, and what becomes possible when you learn to stay connected to yourself while someone else is upset.

This is an edition of Strategy Fridays, where we think about specific things you can do to help manage stress as a highly sensitive person. Imagine someone raises their voice. Maybe it’s your partner, or a family member, or a coworker, or someone you don’t even know very well. They become louder, they become more demanding, and they’re trying to get you to do something their way or to see something their way.

If you’re a highly sensitive person, that moment can feel incredibly uncomfortable, not simply because they’re loud, but because something begins happening inside of you at the same time. Your attention shifts. Instead of asking yourself, “What do I think?” Or, “What do I want?” Or, “What makes sense here?” Your mind becomes occupied with them.

“How do I calm them down? How do I make this better? How do I get us back to peace?” And this is very natural for highly sensitive people because as I like to say, it’s like having your hearing aids turned all the way up so that even when somebody raises their voice a little bit, it is something you register quite strongly when your hearing aids are at that volume.

So that’s the way we are with everything. We hear everything. We’re noticing for nuances. We’re looking for nuances all the time. And when somebody raises their voice, then it is like yelling when we were looking for whispers. So as a result, this can impact us quite strongly as highly sensitive people, but it doesn’t have to impact us as deeply as we tend to think.

Often we think as highly sensitive people that we just can’t handle anything like that at all. My experience is the opposite. Over time, I have become more and more capable of functioning around that kind of negativity or that kind of energy or that kind of controlling or that kind of loudness. And it doesn’t come from me adjusting my hearing aids.

I still hear it all, and it’s still loud. But it’s from what we do, what I do with it internally. So this is what I wanna play with a little bit because I think even if you just use the analogy of hearing again, everyone has an ability to function, at least temporarily, in an extremely loud environment.

Think of a concert you went to. Oh my gosh, I can still hear my ears ringing after doing that when I was younger. And that was before I had earplugs, right? So it– But I was still capable of functioning there. It’s not my favorite, but it’s capable. Or in an emergency situation. I think a lot of HSPs actually, ironically, are very good in certain kinds of situations that require a lot of like th- that are not…

They don’t always shy away from difficult situations. So that doesn’t mean it doesn’t impact us, but what is interesting is that there may be more going on than just the loudness or just the emotion. In fact, when you look at this more closely, I don’t think it’s just about raised voices. I think raised voices are simply one example of something bigger, which is emotional pressure When we’re children, raised voices often mean something important.

It means that adults around us really want us to do something, and they actually have the authority. Sometimes our safety depends on listening to these adults. And sometimes the fastest way back to peace is simply complying. And so we learned as young children that complying is important, that it is not only rewarded, but non-complying is punished, and raised voices is one of those ways that adults used to get our attention and to make us do things.

So the problem is that l- this can carry on into adulthood, and we may still be functioning as if we’re still children under that same kind of condition. So our nervous system learns something very understandable that when someone becomes upset, I better do something, and we snap to, right? We… As HSPs, we like peace, and so we’re naturally compliant.

We naturally want to get rid of that negative experience. And so if compliance will do it, we’ll go there. And so that kind of learning that we better do something makes perfect sense for a child. But when that follows us into adulthood without actually being questioned, then it can end up causing us to be frozen in many different situations that arise

So I think there’s a moment that is easy to miss. When someone becomes upset and then almost instantly what happens is your attention leaves you and then goes to them. A moment ago, you were connected to your own experience, just doing what you’re doing, and suddenly they raise their voice you’re snapped to their attention.

You’re snapped to them. You’re watching them. Like, how upset are they? What do they need? What can I say? How do I make this stop? So notice what just happened. Your own experience, your own perspective quietly disappeared from the conversation. It’s not that you don’t think it’s important, but it’s that your nervous system decided that restoring the emotional state was the priority, and so it just flipped over to them and what do I need to do to make this go away?

I wonder if many highly sensitive people carry a belief that sounds something like this: “I can’t really be okay while they’re upset with me.” If that’s true, then of course someone else’s anger is going to be incredibly powerful because your peace depends on theirs. If they don’t calm down, you can’t calm down.

And so it’s not simply their emotion that’s happening it’s become the condition for your own wellbeing. You are literally dependent on them. So notice it’s a belief. It’s a belief, “I can’t really be okay while they’re upset with me.” As long as I’m believing that, I’m 100% dependent on that person. And so it means that your inner world is gonna be constantly waiting for permission from someone else’s outer world.

If they’re not okay, then I’m gonna not be okay So when another person’s emotion begins feeling more important than your own, even temporarily, then what happens is we tend to try to correct that in one of two ways. We fight, which is generally not the HSP way, but we can get into arguments. So yes, that is one way.

Or we comply. We just give up whatever truth we happen to have and just go with the person who is raising their voice. So that’s it. We– Sometimes we argue and defend ourselves, and sometimes we give in. But notice something interesting. Both reactions are still organized around the other person’s emotional state.

One is trying to overpower it by arguing, and the other is trying to remove their, pa- pacify their emotional state by giving in. Either way, your attention is still centered on them. So that’s the difference. When your attention is centered on them, then you’re still dependent and it feels powerless, and it does not feel like you’re safe in a way.

You’re dependent on them But what if there was another option? Not fighting and not caving. Simply staying connected to yourself. If you remember, what happens when someone raises their voice, the first thing that happens is your attention goes to them. And of course it does. It’s loud. It goes there. It’s emotional.

There’s a threat. So it goes there. But if there’s any way of staying connected to yourself, even while aware of what’s going on with the other person, then that’s the missing piece here in the equation. So what this can look like, instead of immediately asking, “How do I make them stop?” what if you became curious?

What if your curiosity is a more natural state? It’s more connected to oneself to be curious. Okay what are they seeing? What are they wanting? Get curious about that. Maybe ask, maybe think, maybe notice. What is so important to them? And if you do ask, then genuinely listen and find out what’s going on.

A lot of times people’s emotional reactions are coming from them wanting to be heard. And so if you actually listen, which is one of our great traits as an HSP, it– you may start to find that their anger or their whatever emotion it is starts to soften because you’re listening. Now, listening doesn’t mean that you’re condoning.

It doesn’t mean that you’re complying necessarily. It means that you’re listening. You’re listening fairly, and you’re listening openly, and you’re… and you’re not… It’s like they don’t become more right because you’re listening, and they don’t become more right because they’ve spoken loudly.

But they do have some point. So what is that point? I wanna hear. I wanna hear. It’s kinda like listening to yourself when you’re angry and doing inner work. What is that angry part of me thinking? What does it wanna say? What is it trying to get across? There’s something in there. There’s always a kernel of truth in there or some experience, even if it’s not truth.

So that’s the first step. So then the next question is, what do I see? What do I notice here? What’s my experience? And this is the balance to their experience. They have an experience, it’s valid for them. They have something. They’re having a reaction, so what is going on for them? I wanna know. But what is…

what do I see in this situation? What’s my perspective? That’s the one that’s easy to lose. And so this question allows you to stay present more as an equal, to bring yourself in, to invite yourself in Now, equality doesn’t mean everyone has the same role. Like a boss, in this for example, has authority over certain decisions at work.

That’s just the natural part of that position. Or a customer can have legitimate concerns. They have a certain power, in a way. A police officer has a certain authority. Those realities exist, but emotional intensity doesn’t create truth. Someone raising their voice doesn’t automatically make their perspective more valid, and your calmness doesn’t make your perspective less valid.

You both have perspectives. You both have experiences. And from there, a very different conversation becomes possible. You can ask what they see, you can share what and sometimes you’ll discover a solution that works for both of you. And sometimes you won’t. But either way, you haven’t disappeared.

And that, I find, makes listening or being exposed to raised voices or emotional pressure much more easy to put up with, much more not overshadowing. It still has an effect, but not as greatly. What really causes the effect is when I give my power over to somebody and I completely forget mi- about myself.

So the more I remember myself, even in those situations, and see that they have a right to have whatever is going on for them, they have something to offer, even if it’s coming out sideways, and that I also have something to offer. Now, no matter what the authoritative role is, there’s a more of a feeling of equality, and I am present in that situation, and I’m able to experience it with less overwhelm.

So the feeling I’m left with today is that staying connected to yourself and sharing what can go a long way towards staying grounded under someone’s emotional pressure. But there’s a huge difference between sharing what versus arguing to win. One is still a power struggle. One is still trying to get them to see what in other words, it’s all about them. You’re focused on them. They have the authority. You’ve given them the power. And the other is staying in touch with your own experience and sharing it in whatever way is appropriate. Sometimes you may not even share it. You’re just aware of your own experience, and that may be enough just to stay connected to yourself In this episode, we looked at why a raised voice can make it feel like you have no choice even when you do.

And I think it comes down to an energetic thing, that it’s hard to win an argument when you’re a highly sensitive person. We don’t go for the tactics that generally win arguments. We may have a good logic, but someone is gonna come at us energetically. And so energetically, we’re gonna be outgunned.

And so that leaves us feeling like I think you’ll find, at least I do, that over the years, I don’t really have the option of fighting. I can try, but I am not that great at outgunning other people with my emotions. And so that leaves really just one choice, which is to comply, and that’s why it can feel like you have no choice.

We also looked at how your attention quietly shifts away from yourself and onto the other person, and this again leads to that feeling of no choice because you are now in the back seat and they’re driving, and you’re just having to go wherever they go. And then finally, we looked at what becomes possible when you learn to stay connected to yourself while someone else is upset.

I remember the first time I noticed this. It was like seeing someone’s upset as like a little thunderstorm going on over in their world and just allowing that. That alone is… gives so much space. And then as long as I stay connected to myself, then I can bring in my perspective. Maybe there’s a win-win.

But in any case, there’s gonna be less overwhelm if I’m more connected to my own experience So thank you for listening. It’s always great to explore with you. This program comes out three times a week on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays. Join me next time for Breakthrough Mondays, where I share success stories and helpful insights for highly sensitive people on the path towards inner freedom.

Are You Ready to Reduce Overwhelm
and Stress in Your Life?

Take the HSP Stress Test now. Not only will you learn if you are a highly sensitive person (HSP) but you will gain valuable insights into your levels of anxiety, depression, and overall stress. You’ll also get a free 15-minute Inner Freedom Call to uncover what’s holding you back and help you step into a life of true inner freedom and fulfillment.

Stress Management for Highly Sensitive People

Are you a highly sensitive person (HSP) or someone who identifies as hypersensitive or neurodivergent? This podcast is dedicated to helping highly sensitive people (HSPs) navigate overwhelm and stress by using The Work of Byron Katie—a powerful method for questioning stressful thoughts and finding true inner freedom.

We dive deep into stress management strategies, coping with stress, and stress relief methods specifically tailored for HSPs. Learn how to manage emotions, especially negative ones, and explore effective stress reduction techniques that go beyond the surface to address the root causes of anxiety and pressure.

Whether you’re interested in learning how to lower stress, handle stress and pressure, or reduce stress through practical techniques, we provide insights and support based on The Work of Byron Katie. Discover how this transformative approach can help you decrease stress, find inner peace, and create balance in your life.

Join us to learn about various coping strategies for stress, all designed to support HSPs in their journey toward emotional well-being.